Why the same material costs different amounts across the street
Retail pricing is set by the banner, not by the commodity. Two stores a few kilometres apart buy on different contracts, run promotions on different weeks, and price against different local competition. Nothing about the product changes.
In our Quebec price observations, gaps of 10 to 25 percent on identical items are routine. And crucially, no single store is cheapest on everything. The store that wins on drywall loses on insulation, and next month they trade places.